Hardware by Jack Butcher.

Hardware (2025)

Title
Hardware
Year
2025
Medium
Digital artwork; Ethereum
Edition
544
Created
231 of 544, per the contract on 13 November 2026
Collaborators
Highlight
Exhibited
Released online

Hardware is 544 pictures of artworks you can't see.

Each one shows a frame wrapped in plastic. Tape, stickers, barcodes, sometimes a signature. The labels say things like JACK BUTCHER and 1988, the year Butcher was born.

A machine drew all of it, labels included. Look closely and some of the words stop being words. No institution issued any of it.

The work is about the props we use to trust an object. Frames, labels, dates, signatures. How much of that authority is just appearance?

If the label is all you can see, what is it vouching for?

Hardware #1
#1
Hardware #2
#2
Hardware #3
#3
Hardware #4
#4
Hardware #5
#5
Hardware #6
#6
Hardware #7
#7
Hardware #8
#8
Hardware #9
#9
Hardware #10
#10
Hardware #11
#11
Hardware #12
#12

The earlier work, 1988

On 19 March 2024 the Guardian reported that three Damien Hirst formaldehyde works dated to the 1990s were made in 2017. A museum that showed one said the studio "signed off our artwork label before printing."

Four days later Butcher posted 1988, an open edition on Base, an Ethereum layer 2. It was a 3D model you could project into a room with augmented reality. The title borrows from Hirst's shark, The Physical Impossibility of Death in the Mind of Someone Living (1991).

His article on Hardware says 1988 "combines Hirst's formaldehyde works, the central example in the backdating controversy, with the three possible black checks in Butcher's original exploration of digital verification, Checks."4,2

1988 on OpenSea

@jackbutcher
The Physical Impossibility of Provenance
Image attached to the post

View on X

@jackbutcher
1988 takes this to its logical extreme by linking an artwork’s “origin” to the year of my birth. The name itself references Damien Hirst’s practice of backdating artworks to the year they were conceived rather than when they were made.
Image attached to the post

View on X

The release

Hardware opened on 1 January 2025, built with Highlight. The only way in was 1988.

Each claim writes a new token with its year as metadata. In Butcher's words, "Each piece of work is brought into existence by a collector."

The next morning's count is below, and it checks out. 1 + 2 + … + 138 = 9,591. By 21 May 2025 there were 185. All 544 would take 148,240 copies.1,2,3

Hardware #1burn 1 copy of 1988
#2burn 2 copies
#nburn n copies
Plus gasto move from Base to Ethereum mainnet
Edition544
@jackbutcher
Just pay gas (to cover the migration to L1). Provvenance, innit.

View on X

@jackbutcher
9,591 "1988" burned. 138 "Hardware" redeemed. Some more info on process below.
Image attached to the post

View on X

Generating and choosing

Butcher refined a prompt in Flux 1.1 Pro Ultra, through Krea, two images at a time. Around 1,000 tries. Then he ran the Flux API 1,000 images at a time and picked 544 from about 10,000.

The model makes variations. The choice is the authorship.1

@jackbutcher
The prompt is refined two images at a time, in this case using Flux 1.1 Pro Ultra via the Krea AI front end. Each render takes a couple of minutes, probably around 1,000 takes to get the prompt right.
Image attached to the post

View on X

@jackbutcher
Once the prompt is nailed, plug straight into the Flux API and render 1,000 images at a time.
Image attached to the post

View on X

@jackbutcher
Pour a cold one and pick 544 of your favorites from 10,000~ images.
Image attached to the post

View on X

Evidence and appearance

Every piece carries two records. One is drawn. One is written to a public ledger.

A label can suggest a history without establishing one. Hardware puts the two side by side.3

The label in the pictureThe token on Ethereum
Made byAn image modelThe Hardware contract, 0x0c3d…7fe7
SaysJACK BUTCHER, 1988, a barcode, a museum-like nameToken number, owner's wallet, a link to the image
Date1988Year: 2025
Issued byNo oneMinted when a collector claims it
Check itNo issuer to check withAny Ethereum explorer
Hardware #1
Hardware #1. Labels read JACK BUTCHER 1988 and JACK BUTCHER NC. MUSEUM, 1988. Its token metadata reads "How to frame a story."

In Butcher's work

Hardware sits in a run of works about who gets to vouch for things.

Art history

Hardware makes the apparatus of authentication the artwork and leaves out the work being authenticated. That has a history.5,6,7,8,9,10,11

  • 1917

    Marcel Duchamp, Fountain

    A urinal from a plumbing showroom, signed "R. Mutt" and refused by a show with no jury. An unsigned editorial in The Blind Man defended it. "He CHOSE it."

  • 1935-41

    Marcel Duchamp, Box in a Valise

    A leather case of miniature replicas and reproductions of his own work, with one "original" drawing. The case carried the authority.

  • 1968

    Marcel Broodthaers, Musée d'Art Moderne, Département des Aigles

    A museum with "neither permanent collection nor permanent location". Its sections were reproductions, fine-art crates, wall inscriptions and film. Rachel Haidu reads all of his art through its relationship to language. Hardware is the crate with nothing inside.

  • 1971

    Seth Siegelaub and Bob Projansky, The Artist's Reserved Rights Transfer and Sale Agreement

    A contract meant to follow a work from owner to owner. If an owner "ever wants to sell it, repair it, appraise it or authenticate it, he MUST come to you". A token keeps that list of owners in public by default.

  • 1975

    Hans Haacke, Seurat's "Les Poseuses" (small version), 1888-1975

    Fourteen panels listing who owned one Seurat painting, beside a reproduction of it. The provenance is the artwork. The Art Institute of Chicago's record of the piece notes a copy of Siegelaub's Artist's Agreement in its file.

  • 1989

    Andrea Fraser, Museum Highlights: A Gallery Talk

    A fictional docent tours the restrooms and the cafeteria in the museum's own vocabulary. The tone of authority, pointed at the wrong object.

Posts

By @jackbutcher, quoted exactly. Trailing media links are left out.

@jackbutcher

Article on X

"Hardware" is an examination of the nuance of artistic provenance in the year 2025.

Read the article on X

@jackbutcher
"Hardware" exposes the fragility of physical authenticity systems by turning their visual cues into deliberate fictions.
Image attached to the post

View on X

@jackbutcher
No matter how art is framed, labeled, or verified, its meaning ultimately resides in how it’s perceived.
Image attached to the post

View on X

@jackbutcher
hardware asks: what is the role of the object when the value is the network?
Image attached to the post

View on X

More from the thread

Collectors

Adam Hollander @HollanderAdam
Hardware #44 from @jackbutcher. 44 = half of 88, burned from 44X 1988 VV OE. To the vault it goes 🔒

View on X

winn.eth @winntunnel
Hardware #161 such a smooth mint process and was able to learn more about L2/L1 in the process. Thanks for making me think @jackbutcher Also have what you have been doing on @rodeodotclub

View on X

pravijn @pravijn
Jack Butcher, Hardware #65 ca. 2025

View on X

100 works

Hardware #1 to #100, shown smaller. Click any work for its original.

Download all 100 (ZIP, 437 MB)

Hardware #1
#1
Hardware #2
#2
Hardware #3
#3
Hardware #4
#4
Hardware #5
#5
Hardware #6
#6
Hardware #7
#7
Hardware #8
#8
Hardware #9
#9
Hardware #10
#10
Hardware #11
#11
Hardware #12
#12
Hardware #13
#13
Hardware #14
#14
Hardware #15
#15
Hardware #16
#16
Hardware #17
#17
Hardware #18
#18
Hardware #19
#19
Hardware #20
#20
Hardware #21
#21
Hardware #22
#22
Hardware #23
#23
Hardware #24
#24
Hardware #25
#25
Hardware #26
#26
Hardware #27
#27
Hardware #28
#28
Hardware #29
#29
Hardware #30
#30
Hardware #31
#31
Hardware #32
#32
Hardware #33
#33
Hardware #34
#34
Hardware #35
#35
Hardware #36
#36
Hardware #37
#37
Hardware #38
#38
Hardware #39
#39
Hardware #40
#40
Hardware #41
#41
Hardware #42
#42
Hardware #43
#43
Hardware #44
#44
Hardware #45
#45
Hardware #46
#46
Hardware #47
#47
Hardware #48
#48
Hardware #49
#49
Hardware #50
#50
Hardware #51
#51
Hardware #52
#52
Hardware #53
#53
Hardware #54
#54
Hardware #55
#55
Hardware #56
#56
Hardware #57
#57
Hardware #58
#58
Hardware #59
#59
Hardware #60
#60
Hardware #61
#61
Hardware #62
#62
Hardware #63
#63
Hardware #64
#64
Hardware #65
#65
Hardware #66
#66
Hardware #67
#67
Hardware #68
#68
Hardware #69
#69
Hardware #70
#70
Hardware #71
#71
Hardware #72
#72
Hardware #73
#73
Hardware #74
#74
Hardware #75
#75
Hardware #76
#76
Hardware #77
#77
Hardware #78
#78
Hardware #79
#79
Hardware #80
#80
Hardware #81
#81
Hardware #82
#82
Hardware #83
#83
Hardware #84
#84
Hardware #85
#85
Hardware #86
#86
Hardware #87
#87
Hardware #88
#88
Hardware #89
#89
Hardware #90
#90
Hardware #91
#91
Hardware #92
#92
Hardware #93
#93
Hardware #94
#94
Hardware #95
#95
Hardware #96
#96
Hardware #97
#97
Hardware #98
#98
Hardware #99
#99
Hardware #100
#100

Development

  1. 1988 posted. Source

  2. Release thread. 1988 becomes redeemable for Hardware. Source

  3. Process posts. 138 redeemed. Source

  4. Article on X. Source

  5. 185 created. Source

  6. jack.art note with Rachel Haidu. Source

  7. Contract reports 231. Source

Notes on the record

  1. This is a dated account of the release, not current redemption guidance.1,2,3
  2. The contract's totalSupply on 13 November 2026, and arithmetic from the stated rule, is used here.1,2,3
  3. These are the artist's process estimates.1
  4. This reading concerns the work's premise; it does not imply that all provenance research is futile.3

Sources and further reading

  1. 1. Artist / studio · Selected posts from the downloaded account archive

    Hardware release thread and process posts

    10 selected posts on the release and the image-generation and selection process. Original wording and links are preserved; headings and notes are editorial. This is artist testimony, not independent verification.

  2. 2. Artist / studio · Article on X

    Hardware (article on X)

    Hardware is an examination of the nuance of artistic provenance in the year 2025.

  3. 3. Technical reference · Blockchain contract

    Hardware by Jack Butcher, Ethereum contract 0x0c3dd3c403b6b5c0cce2a97f15820a4eae347fe7

    Contract data on 13 November 2026.

  4. 4. Independent publication · Investigative reporting

    Damien Hirst formaldehyde animal works dated to 1990s were made in 2017

    Reports backdating and a museum statement about label approval.

  5. 5. Historical reference · Museum exhibition record

    Marcel Duchamp and the Fountain Scandal

    Documents the 1917 work and its history.

  6. 6. Historical reference · Museum collection record

    Marcel Duchamp, Box in a Valise, 1935-41

    Documents the portable museum.

  7. 7. Historical reference · Museum exhibition record

    Museum as Muse: Broodthaers

    Documents the Musée d'Art Moderne, Département des Aigles.

  8. 8. Historical reference · Art history monograph

    Rachel Haidu, The Absence of Work: Marcel Broodthaers, 1964-1976

    Critical study of Broodthaers.

  9. 9. Historical reference · Historical document

    Seth Siegelaub, The Artist's Reserved Rights Transfer and Sale Agreement (1971)

    Contract meant to follow artworks through ownership chains.

  10. 10. Historical reference · Museum collection record

    Hans Haacke, Seurat's "Les Poseuses" (small version), 1888-1975

    Documents the provenance artwork.

  11. 11. Historical reference · Museum documentation

    Andrea Fraser, Museum Highlights: A Gallery Talk

    Documents the 1989 performance.

Related work and context