Notes /

Checks Elements

Checks Elements: a composition of colored checkmarks on paper.

Checks Elements is 152 pairs. Each pair is a monoprint and a digital work on Ethereum. Jean Milant and Cirrus Editions printed them in 2023. The compositions come from the same generative rules as Checks, and the palettes are sorted by the four classical elements, earth, air, fire and water.

The process runs in an unusual direction. Every image started as code. Then Jean drew each one by hand from its instructions and pulled it on a Mailander 202 lithographic press. Every print has a digital twin, and the token records whether a collector holds one or both.

William M. Ivins Jr. published Prints and Visual Communication with Harvard University Press in 1953. His argument is that people had been looking at prints the wrong way. They treated them as art objects, valued only when they could be called works of art. For Ivins the real importance was plainer. Printing pictures "made possible for the first time pictorial statements of a kind that could be exactly repeated, during the effective life of the printing surface." He goes further than that. "It is hardly too much to say that since the invention of writing there has been no more important invention than that of the exactly repeatable pictorial statement."

Put that next to Checks Elements and the roles swap. Here the exactly repeatable statement is the token. Anyone can read the same data and get the same image, every time, for as long as the chain runs. The press, the machine Ivins credited with repetition, is where the variation comes in. A monoprint gives you one pull. The ink lands a little differently, the hand drifts, and the sheet is the only one of its kind.

Ivins also noticed that the people who wrote about art mostly worked from copies. Historians and theorists, he says, built "most of their thought" on "exactly repeatable pictorial statements about works of art rather than upon first-hand acquaintance with them." The reproduction quietly shaped what they thought the original was.

Later in the book he describes a pair of Degas pictures at the Metropolitan Museum. One is built on a monotype. The other is built on a counterproof of the same monotype. As images they are "mirror images of each other exactly alike but in different directions." And yet "they are so different that many people do not recognize their close relation to each other."

That is close to what a Checks Elements pair is. Same composition, same instructions, two objects that behave nothing alike. One of them can be copied perfectly by anyone. The other one Jean touched.

The edition is built from multiples of the four elements. Alpha, 4. Order, 12. Isolate, 16. Composite, 24. Compound, 32. Complete, 64. Christie's showed three of the works, Earth, Air and Water, at its Rockefeller Center galleries in New York from 20 to 23 May 2023. Checks Elements #82 is now in the permanent collection of the Los Angeles County Museum of Art.

A collector who holds both has the exact one and the singular one. The token keeps a record of whether they stayed together.

Sources